The Return Season is here! Retain over 40% of your returns as exchanges! - Learn More
    • Tracking & Notifications

      Boost customer experience and reduce support tickets

      Identify and Resolve Order Issues

      Realtime order and shipment tracking

      Delivery Notifications

      Proactive order and shipping notifications

      Increase Conversion Rate

      Predictive pre-purchase estimated delivery dates

      Branded Tracking

      Self-Serivce branded order tracking

      Reduce Operational Cost

      Effortless experience delivered

      Returns & Exchanges

      Make returns profitable and delight customers

      Flexible Return Policies

      Flexibility to define any return destinations & conditions

      Self-Service Returns

      Simplify returns for your customers and team


      Incentivize exchanges over returns

      Automate Returns Management

      Returns management made easy for your team

      Returns Analytics

      Understand why your customers are returning

      In-Store and Curbside Pickup

      Unify the online and the in-store experience

      Curbside Pickup Check-in

      Hassle-free pickup experience for customers

      Pickup order management

      In-Store Dashboard to keep operations streamlined

      Unified Commerce

      In-Store and Online orders unified

      Store Locator

      Drive foot-traffic to your stores

  • Integrations
  • Customers
    • Help Center

      Find the answer to all your questions

      WeSupply FAQ

      Explore the most comon questions about WeSupply

      Post Purchase ROI Calculator

      Calculate the ROI that WeSupply can bring you

      FREE Website Review

      Request a no strings attached review of your current shopping experience and missed conversion opportunities

      Blog & Guides

      Read actionable articles on how to optimize your post-purchase experience and decrease support tickets

      Case Studies

      Get inspired by stories of how our customers implemented an effortless post-purchase experience

      Behind The Brand

      A Deep Dive into Top Companies' Order Tracking & Returns Strategy

      Pre-built Return Policies

      Wondering if WeSupply is a good fit for you? Read through our use cases to see how we can help you increase conversion & improve CX!

  • Pricing

Sign in

Top Strategies for Preventing Ecommerce Return Fraud Effectively

blocking fraudulent customers

Ecommerce return fraud—a trickery costing your business time and money. How do you stop it? This guide cuts to the chase, offering you concrete strategies for preventing ecommerce return fraud. From strengthening your return policy to leveraging technology and analytics, we’re diving deep into the tools you need to protect your business. Expect to emerge with actionable tactics that can be implemented today.

Key Takeaways

Introduction to Ecommerce Return Fraud

Imagine this: an online shopper buys an electronic item, uses it for a weekend party, and then returns it for a full refund. This is a classic example of wardrobing, a common type of return fraud. It’s not just wardrobing; empty box scams, receipt fraud, stolen merchandise return – the list goes on. Return fraud is more than a mere headache for online retailers; it inflicts a financial burden costing the ecommerce industry billions.

Online retailers are grappling with different types of return fraud incidents, each more inventive than the last. For instance, in an empty box scam, fraudsters return the box empty or filled with junk, claiming the original item was inside. In a stolen merchandise return, stolen items are returned for a refund or store credit, draining financial resources and eating up valuable time.

Detecting return fraud is a challenge, given the sophisticated methods used by fraudsters. Empty box scams, for instance, are difficult to detect until the returned boxes are opened. Similarly, receipt fraud, where fake or altered receipts are used to return stolen goods, is hard to spot without meticulous checks. How can ecommerce businesses counteract this menace? One way is to detect return fraud and implement return fraud prevention strategies.

Understanding and Identifying Common Types of Return Fraud

As we delve into the complexities of return fraud, we come across various forms it can take. Each has its unique modus operandi, and understanding these tactics is the first step towards return fraud prevention.

Take wardrobing, for instance. It’s a fraudulent practice where items, especially expensive ones like designer clothes or electronics, are purchased with the intent to use and then return. Can you imagine buying a high-end dress, wearing it for a gala event, and then returning it the next day claiming it wasn’t the right fit? This practice is known as wardrobing.

Next, we have box scams, which come in two flavors – empty box and box fraud. In an empty box scam, the fraudster returns an empty box, tricking the online store into thinking it contains the returned item. In box fraud, the fraudster replaces the original item with a worthless item of similar weight. Talk about getting a box of rocks when you expect a designer handbag!

Receipt fraud is another common type of return fraud where fraudsters manipulate or forge receipts to return stolen merchandise for cash. Imagine a fraudster shoplifting an item, then producing a forged receipt to return the stolen item for a full refund. The audacity, right? This is a clear example of return abuse, and it’s one of the ways return fraud occurs.

Having explored common forms of return fraud, let’s now turn our attention towards their prevention.

Implementing and Enhancing Return Policies

Return policies are the first line of defense against return fraud. A well-crafted return policy not only helps prevent return fraud but also ensures customer satisfaction. What determines the effectiveness of a return policy? A successful policy hinges on several crucial elements.

First and foremost, the policy should be clear and concise. Ambiguity is a fraudster’s best friend. By clearly outlining what can be returned, under what conditions, and within what timeframe, you minimize the room for misinterpretation or manipulation. Additionally, consider including provisions for inspecting returned items and reserve the right to refuse returns that don’t meet the policy’s criteria.

Bear in mind, drafting an effective return policy isn’t a one-off task. It’s a continuous process that requires regular updating to keep pace with emerging fraud trends and customer behavior. For instance, if you notice an uptick in empty box scams, you might want to introduce more rigorous checks before processing refunds. Similarly, if you find that a large number of your customers are returning items just after the holiday season, you might want to revise your return policy accordingly.

WeSupply’s pre-built return policies provide a streamlined solution for businesses looking to implement or enhance their return strategies. These templates are expertly crafted to address common concerns and legal requirements, ensuring a hassle-free setup. By using these pre-built policies, companies can quickly establish clear and fair return protocols, enhancing customer trust and satisfaction while minimizing potential legal headaches.

One example of WeSupply’s Pre-Built Policies tailored for minimizing fraud is the Blocklist feature. This policy allows businesses to blocklist specific email addresses or customer groups, effectively preventing fraudulent customers from returning products. By implementing a strategic blocklist system, companies can target and mitigate fraudulent behavior, thereby safeguarding their interests and revenue. The importance of this approach cannot be overstated, as a smart return policy paired with a blocklist system not only increases customer loyalty but also reduces return abuse and maintains profitability. Without such measures, businesses risk continued abuse, lost revenue, and a tarnished brand reputation.

Speed up returns process

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply’s self-service returns makes it super easy for your customers to return anything, anytime – without needing to submit customer support tickets or call in!

Utilizing Advanced Technology and Analytics

In the battle against return fraud, technology and analytics make formidable allies. From return management software to machine learning and behavioral analytics, these tools play a key role in detecting and preventing fraudulent returns.

Return management software, for instance, helps monitor returns and track return patterns. It can flag multiple returns from the same customer or excessive returns of the same item, both potential red flags for fraudulent activity.

Machine learning and behavioral analytics take this a step further. By learning from past data, machine learning algorithms can predict potential fraud incidents. Behavioral analytics, on the other hand, helps spot suspicious behavior by comparing it against established customer behavior profiles. For instance, if a customer suddenly starts returning high-value items frequently, it could indicate a possible fraud attempt.

WeSupply leverages advanced technology and analytics to enhance its return management system, significantly reducing the incidence of returns fraud and providing deep insights into return patterns. Here are some of the key features that empower businesses:

  • Fraud Prevention System: Automatically detects and blocks customers attempting to abuse the return policy, integrating seamlessly with existing block lists to prevent known abusers from making returns.
  • Customizable Detection Settings: Allows businesses to configure how to detect policy abusers and determine the outcomes, ensuring flexibility and control over the return process.

  • Block List Customer Group: Enables the creation of a block list for customers who are identified as frequent abusers, preventing them from returning non-returnable items and avoiding unnecessary refunds.

  • Returns Analytics: Provides detailed insights into return patterns, identifying the most returned products and the reasons behind these returns, as well as pinpointing serial returners.

By using these advanced capabilities, WeSupply helps businesses maintain trusted client relationships while minimizing losses due to fraudulent returns. Book a demo with WeSupply and see how easy managing returns can be!

Empowering and Training Employees

Despite advancements in technology, human judgment continues to be an invaluable asset in the fight against return fraud. Hence, investing in employee training is crucial.

Training employees to identify potential red flags indicative of fraudulent returns is imperative. These could include frequent returns by the same customer, returns of high-value items, or returns with missing or damaged original packaging.

Beyond recognizing fraud tactics, employees must also be equipped to handle such situations adeptly. This includes:

  • Understanding the company’s return policies

  • Knowing how to inspect returned items for signs of use or damage

  • Being aware of the correct procedures to follow when fraud is suspected.

With WeSupply’s Automated Returns Management, businesses can significantly empower their employees by streamlining return processes and reducing manual workloads. This automation allows staff to focus on more critical tasks, enhancing overall efficiency and service quality. Key features that facilitate this improvement include:

  • 24/7 Returns Processing: Automates the entire return process with predefined rules and logics, enabling returns at any time without human intervention.
  • Automated Return Labels and Notifications: Automatically generates return labels and sends notifications to customers, reducing manual tasks for employees.

  • Image and Feedback Collection: Allows customers to upload images and describe issues on the returns page, eliminating the need for back-and-forth emails and providing valuable information for quality assessments.

  • Error Reduction: Automates calculations for conditional restocking fees and the validation of returnable versus non-returnable items, minimizing user errors.

  • Quality Control and Inventory Management: Facilitates detailed inspections and quality control of returned items, with the capability for warehouse staff to add notes about each return’s condition, improving inventory management.

This suite of tools not only simplifies the returns process but also enhances the capability of employees to manage and resolve returns efficiently and effectively.

Monitoring, Analyzing, and Managing Data

Data provides a treasure trove of insights for spotting and preventing return fraud. By tracking and analyzing return data, online retailers can spot potential fraud and take preventive action. For instance, by analyzing return patterns, retailers can identify customers who frequently return items or return high-value items. Similarly, analyzing customer behavior data can help spot suspicious behavior, such as a sudden increase in the value or frequency of returns.

However, relying solely on data isn’t sufficient. Rigorous checks and return authorization processes are essential before processing refunds. A return merchandise authorization (RMA) system can be particularly effective here, allowing retailers to track returns and identify fraudulent patterns.

WeSupply offers comprehensive tools for monitoring, analyzing, and managing data, enabling businesses to optimize their returns process and make data-driven decisions. This advanced analytics capability helps companies understand and act on customer return patterns, ultimately reducing return rates and enhancing operational efficiency. Key features include:

  • Returns Analytics: Gathers insights into the most returned products and the reasons behind these returns, as well as identifying serial returners.
  • Actionable Insights: Utilizes returns data to provide actionable insights that help reduce the overall return rate, with integration capabilities such as BigQuery for advanced data analysis.

  • Automated Returns Management: Minimizes RMA costs by automating processes from returns to exchanges, and from reshipments to warranties, reducing manual touchpoints and errors.

  • Enhanced Efficiency and Communication: Supports an activity log for RMAs that records every action taken during the returns process, visible to cross functional teams. This ensures that everyone involved can see the latest status of a return, when the product will arrive at the warehouse, and the amount refunded.

By leveraging these tools, businesses can not only save time and money but also improve the accuracy and efficiency of their returns management systems.

Collaborating to Combat Fraud

The responsibility of preventing return fraud lies collectively. By collaborating and sharing data and strategies, online retailers can strengthen their defenses against return fraud.

For instance, online retailers could share data on fraudulent returns, helping each other spot and prevent similar fraud attempts. They could also share successful fraud prevention strategies, enhancing the industry’s collective capacity to combat return fraud.

Successful collaborative efforts have already shown the potential of this approach. For example, the National Retail Federation in the United States has been instrumental in facilitating industry collaboration to combat return fraud, resulting in significant reductions in fraud incidents.

Alternative Solutions and Customer Communication

Balancing the prevention of return fraud with the need to not adversely affect legitimate customers is of paramount importance for brick and mortar stores. One way to do this is by offering alternative solutions like store credits and exchanges instead of cash refunds. Store credits and exchanges are less attractive to fraudsters as they don’t offer a direct cash benefit. At the same time, they provide genuine customers with the flexibility to choose another item if the original purchase didn’t meet their expectations.

Nonetheless, these measures must go hand in hand with effective communication with customers. Customers need to be educated about return policies and the consequences of fraudulent returns. This not only helps deter potential fraudsters but also ensures that genuine customers understand their rights and responsibilities when returning items.

WeSupply’s pre-built return policies offer versatile and customer-focused solutions that enhance communication and provide alternative return options, particularly during peak shopping times like the holiday season. These policies are designed to improve customer satisfaction while protecting the business from return fraud. Key features include:

  • Holiday Sale Returns: Allows returns on items purchased on sale during the holiday season, boosting customer satisfaction and loyalty by accommodating their unique needs during this busy period.
  • Extended Holiday Return Window: Provides an extended return window during the holiday seasons, giving customers more flexibility and enhancing their overall shopping experience.
  • Free Returns on Exchanges: Offers free return shipping on exchanges, which can increase customer loyalty and enhance satisfaction by making the process more convenient and cost-effective for shoppers.
  • Anti-Fraud Measures for Serial Returners: Implements robust systems to identify and manage serial returners, significantly reducing return fraud. This tailored approach ensures a fair process for all customers while preserving the company’s revenue and protecting its reputation.

These strategic policies ensure that customers enjoy a seamless and fair return process, encouraging repeat business and building trust. Discover a smoother return process! Book a demo with WeSupply today and see how easy returns can be!

Create custom return policies

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply can help you take control of returns by creating custom policies to handle them all easily. You get to decide how you want to handle final sale items, return window lengths, return request approvals, and more.

If your eCommerce store is running on the Magento 2 platform, you can check out the awesome WeltPixel MaxMind Fraud Prevention extension, which is designed specifically to bring MaxMind’s (one of the leading Fraud Prevention platforms in the eCommerce space) services over to the Magento 2 platform. The extension is officially endorsed by MaxMind and is one of the most powerful available on the market!

Future Outlook and Innovations

Looking ahead, it’s evident that the fight against return fraud will undergo continual evolution. New technologies and methodologies are being developed to further combat return fraud, and ecommerce businesses will need to adapt their fraud prevention strategies to keep pace.

For instance, we can expect to see more sophisticated return management software equipped with advanced machine learning algorithms. These tools will be able to detect even subtle patterns indicative of fraud, allowing retailers to react promptly and effectively.

Simultaneously, we foresee ecommerce businesses consistently refining their return policies to combat return fraud ecommerce, enhancing communication strategies, and fortifying employee training programs. By doing so, they can ensure that they stay one step ahead of the fraudsters while still providing an excellent customer experience.

Conclusion: Best Practices and Key Takeaways

In conclusion, it’s evident that an effective prevention of ecommerce return fraud necessitates a holistic approach. The key elements of this approach include:

  • Clear-cut return policies

  • Rigorous data analysis

  • Employee training

  • Industry collaboration

Each of these elements plays a vital role in combating return fraud and protecting ecommerce businesses.

However, preventing return fraud isn’t just about protecting your bottom line; it’s also about maintaining your reputation and ensuring customer satisfaction. By taking a proactive stance against return fraud, you can ensure that your ecommerce business remains:

  • Profitable

  • Reputable

  • Customer-friendly

  • Able to handle evolving ecommerce challenges

So, are you prepared to face the challenge of curbing return fraud? With the strategies and insights shared in this blog post, you’re well equipped to do so. Here’s to your success in combating return fraud!


In conclusion, return fraud is a significant issue facing ecommerce businesses today. However, with a comprehensive strategy that includes clear return policies, advanced technology, employee training, data analysis, industry collaboration, and effective customer communication, it is a battle that you can win. Remember, the key to success lies not just in detecting and preventing fraud, but also in maintaining customer satisfaction and loyalty.

WeSupply is a comprehensive solution designed to effectively prevent ecommerce return fraud while enhancing the customer return experience. The platform combines advanced technology, automated management, and insightful analytics to streamline return processes and reduce fraud. Key features include a fraud prevention system that detects and blocks policy abusers, customizable detection settings, a block list customer group, and detailed returns analytics that identify patterns and serial returners. WeSupply also simplifies operations with 24/7 automated returns processing, automated return labels, and the collection of product images and feedback. Furthermore, it enhances efficiency and communication with a robust activity log for RMAs and provides actionable insights through data integration with tools like BigQuery. The system includes pre-built return policies that allow returns on sale items during holidays, extended holiday return windows, and free returns on exchanges, all tailored to reduce return fraud and improve customer loyalty. Ready to enhance your return process and combat fraud? Get started with WeSupply today!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is return fraud?

Return fraud is when customers misuse online retailers’ return policies, causing financial losses for the businesses.

What are some common types of return fraud?

Return fraud commonly includes wardrobing, empty box scams, receipt fraud, and stolen merchandise return. Be vigilant against these tactics to protect your business.

How can ecommerce businesses prevent return fraud?

To prevent return fraud, ecommerce businesses should implement clear return policies, use advanced technology, train employees, monitor and analyze data, collaborate with other businesses, and communicate effectively with customers. This comprehensive approach can help minimize return fraud and protect the business.

How does WeSupply prevent return fraud?

WeSupply uses an advanced fraud prevention system that detects and blocks customers who attempt to abuse return policies. It integrates seamlessly with existing block lists to prevent known abusers from making returns, thereby protecting your revenue and maintaining fairness in the return process.

Can WeSupply customize how returns are managed?

Yes, WeSupply allows businesses to customize detection settings to identify return policy abusers and determine appropriate actions. This flexibility helps tailor the return process to specific business needs and customer behaviors.

What analytics does WeSupply provide to help understand return patterns?

WeSupply offers comprehensive returns analytics that help businesses identify the most returned products, understand the reasons behind these returns, and pinpoint serial returners. This data is crucial for making informed decisions to reduce return rates.

Does WeSupply have an official Shopify App?

Yes, WeSupply does have an official Shopify App. You can download and begin to integrate it with your Shopify store.

Does WeSupply have an official Magento extension?

Yes, WeSupply has an official extension for Magento. The WeSupply x Magento integration allows for automating order tracking experiences, reducing customer inquiries, automating shipping email and SMS notifications, and providing a fully branded order tracking experience

Does WeSupply have an official BigCommerce App?

Yes, WeSupply has an official BigCommerce App. You can integrate WeSupply with your BigCommerce store to improve your post-purchase customer experience.

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

WeSupply Post Purchase Emails
WeSupply Post Purchase Emails

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

Jump Ahead!

In this article you'll learn:

Learn How To Create Successful Post Purchase Email Campaigns

Build an effective post-purchase email flow that helps you increase customer satisfaction and drive revenue growth!

Consumers seek the best deals on:

Related articles