The Return Season is here! Retain over 40% of your returns as exchanges! - Learn More
    • Tracking & Notifications

      Boost customer experience and reduce support tickets

      Identify and Resolve Order Issues

      Realtime order and shipment tracking

      Delivery Notifications

      Proactive order and shipping notifications

      Increase Conversion Rate

      Predictive pre-purchase estimated delivery dates

      Branded Tracking

      Self-Serivce branded order tracking

      Reduce Operational Cost

      Effortless experience delivered

      Returns & Exchanges

      Make returns profitable and delight customers

      Flexible Return Policies

      Flexibility to define any return destinations & conditions

      Self-Service Returns

      Simplify returns for your customers and team


      Incentivize exchanges over returns

      Automate Returns Management

      Returns management made easy for your team

      Returns Analytics

      Understand why your customers are returning

      In-Store and Curbside Pickup

      Unify the online and the in-store experience

      Curbside Pickup Check-in

      Hassle-free pickup experience for customers

      Pickup order management

      In-Store Dashboard to keep operations streamlined

      Unified Commerce

      In-Store and Online orders unified

      Store Locator

      Drive foot-traffic to your stores

  • Integrations
  • Customers
    • Help Center

      Find the answer to all your questions

      WeSupply FAQ

      Explore the most comon questions about WeSupply

      Post Purchase ROI Calculator

      Calculate the ROI that WeSupply can bring you

      FREE Website Review

      Request a no strings attached review of your current shopping experience and missed conversion opportunities

      Blog & Guides

      Read actionable articles on how to optimize your post-purchase experience and decrease support tickets

      Case Studies

      Get inspired by stories of how our customers implemented an effortless post-purchase experience

      Behind The Brand

      A Deep Dive into Top Companies' Order Tracking & Returns Strategy

      Pre-built Return Policies

      Wondering if WeSupply is a good fit for you? Read through our use cases to see how we can help you increase conversion & improve CX!

  • Pricing

Sign in

Return Policies: What Type of Returns Should You Offer?

Return Policies: What Type of Returns Should You Offer warner bros

Choosing the right return policies type of returns is pivotal to fostering customer trust and ensuring business profitability. Whether considering full refunds, exchanges, or store credit, each affects your bottom line in unique ways. This article offers a clear breakdown of return types, their strategic advantages, and how they contribute to customer loyalty and revenue—crucial insights for establishing a return policy that serves both buyers and sellers effectively.

Key Takeaways

The Importance of Diverse Return Options

A diverse return and refund policy can set your business apart in the competitive ecommerce landscape. Offering a variety of return options not only enhances customer satisfaction, but also encourages loyalty by catering to diverse consumer preferences. Accepting returns indeed forms an integral part of the customer service experience.

From full refunds to exchange policies, the options are numerous, and each carries its unique impact on both the customer experience and your bottom line. Understanding your store’s exchange policy is crucial for maintaining customer satisfaction.

Enhancing Customer Experience

When it comes to online shopping, the speed and ease of refunds significantly influence where customers choose to make their online purchases. In fact, 65% of customers report that a swift exchange process can build trust and improve loyalty. Moreover, offering store credit as a return option gives customers the flexibility to make future purchases without immediate expense, thus enhancing the shopping experience.

Ecommerce stores that offer the option to return items in-store lead to more confident purchase decisions. It allows customers to try on other sizes and reduces the likelihood of future returns. A customer-centric store’s return policy, as reflected in positive reviews and repeat purchases, contributes to business reputation and fosters a higher retention rate and revenue growth.

WeSupply enhances the customer experience in e-commerce with diverse return options. It encourages exchanges over returns to boost sales, offering instant store credit as a reward and directing customers back to the product catalog. Its refund options include automatic issuance of store credit, gift cards, or coupon codes, fostering customer loyalty. The “Buy Online, Return In Store” feature adds convenience, driving traffic to physical stores and reducing online cart abandonment.

Key features:

With these innovative return solutions, WeSupply redefines the online shopping experience. Discover how we can transform your business – book a demo today!

Encouraging Customer Loyalty

Customer loyalty holds immense importance, as evidenced by the 92% of customers who would revisit a store if the return process is smooth. Providing a smooth omnichannel return experience and a consistent return policy, including multiple customer returns methods, significantly strengthens customer loyalty.

Offering store credit as a return option has several benefits:

  • It fosters long-term customer relations

  • It contributes to increased customer lifetime value through repeat purchases

  • Loyal customers who are satisfied with the return process spend 67% more per purchase

These benefits underscore the profit opportunity from customer-friendly returns.

Utilizing returns software and improving services based on return analysis can convert returns into new purchases, thereby retaining customers and expanding the customer base.

WeSupply plays a crucial role in encouraging customer loyalty in the e-commerce sector. Key features include:

Experience the benefits of WeSupply for your e-commerce business. Get started today and transform your customer loyalty and return management!

Adapting to Consumer Preferences

To counteract the environmental impact of returns, a few businesses with a focus on sustainability have initiated restocking fees, encouraging more eco-friendly shopping choices. This adaptation caters to the growing consumer preference for sustainable practices, further enhancing customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Although these fees may initially deter some customers, they also encourage more thoughtful purchasing decisions. This way, businesses can maintain profitability while contributing positively to the environment. It’s about striking a balance between meeting consumer preferences and managing business needs.

WeSupply is adept at adapting to consumer preferences, especially in promoting environmental sustainability in the e-commerce sector. The platform helps decrease carbon emissions associated with returns and exchanges by implementing eco-friendly policies. Some of the features are:

WeSupply adapts to eco-conscious consumer preferences in e-commerce. Our eco-friendly policies reduce carbon emissions and waste. Join us for a greener and more efficient future.

Types of Returns: A Comprehensive Overview

After understanding the significance of diverse return options, we now move to the details. From full refunds to warranties, each type of return has its unique characteristics and impacts on both customer satisfaction and business profitability. Let’s take a closer look at each of these return types and the roles they play in a comprehensive return policy.

Full Refunds

Full refunds are initially attractive to customers seeking assured solutions for return scenarios. However, offering a full refund involves a loss of revenue for the business as the entire purchase price is returned to the customer via their original payment method.

Beyond the immediate monetary loss, full refunds may also contribute to lost future sales, affecting long-term revenue. Although full refunds are customer-friendly and straightforward, they may not be the most profitable choice for businesses in the long term. Hence, pondering over other return options that can potentially conserve revenue within the business becomes vital. Some alternative return options to consider are:

  • Store credit or gift cards

  • Exchanges for different products

  • Partial refunds or discounts

  • Repair or replacement services

By offering these alternatives, businesses can retain some of the revenue while still providing a satisfactory resolution to customers.


Exchanges can be a win-win solution for both businesses and customers. They help retain revenue by providing an alternative to refunds, which keeps the customer’s money within the business. Furthermore, exchanges are a method to keep customers happy by meeting their needs and converting a potential return into a retained sale.

The exchange process also offers businesses the chance to:

  • Increase average order value by upselling or cross-selling

  • Increase revenue and the likelihood of repeat purchases

  • Ensure customer retention and maintain a positive cash flow

  • Minimize losses on customer acquisition and return shipping costs

In fact, 83% of ecommerce stores offer exchanges, indicating the strategy’s effectiveness in achieving these goals.

Store Credit

Store credit is another flexible return option that fosters customer loyalty and boosts overall profits. By choosing to offer store credit, it encourages customers to spend more than the credited amount, contributing to higher average order value and increased revenue for the store.

Store credit offers several benefits for both businesses and customers:

  • It ensures that money from returned items is kept within the business, reducing revenue loss.

  • It provides customers with more flexible return options.

  • Retailers like Home Depot and Target have successfully used store credit as a return option, demonstrating its practical application in the retail scenario.

Gift Cards

Gift cards serve as an effective return option, allowing businesses to retain revenue while ensuring customer satisfaction and encouraging future purchases. Nordstrom, for example, provides refunds on gift cards at the current price of the item when a purchase record cannot be found, contributing to customer retention.

Gift cards can increase the frequency of customer visits, potentially leading to additional sales beyond the value of the card. Unlike store credit, gift cards can be utilized for a wider range of uses, such as applying them toward shipping costs or fees.

Comprehensive Returns and Exchange Solutions by WeSupply

WeSupply offers a comprehensive approach to various types of returns, ensuring a seamless and customer-centric experience. Exchanges are made easy by directing customers back to your website, where they can shop for any product, regardless of price. Additionally:

  • Refunds offered as store credit, gift cards, or coupon codes to encourage repeat purchases and trust-building.

  • Incentives for exchanges over returns, saving sales and increasing average order values through instant store credit.

  • Ability to convert returns into exchanges with options like exchanging for any product, reshipping the same item, swapping for an item of the same value, or upgrading to a higher-valued item.

Elevate your returns process with WeSupply and provide customers with a seamless and rewarding experience, boosting both loyalty and sales for your business.

Incentivize exchanges over returns

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply can help you save sales through exchanges and boost the average order value using instant store credit.

Crafting an Effective Return Policy

Having understood the various types of returns, the next step is crafting an effective return policy that balances customer satisfaction with business profitability. A clear and comprehensive return policy is an agreement between customers and a business regarding the conditions under which items can be returned for a refund or exchange and plays a crucial role in shaping the customer’s shopping experience.

Communicating Your Policy Clearly

A clear and transparent return policy ensures consistency in operations and sets clear expectations, positively impacting the brand. It’s crucial to use simple and concise language in the return policy to make it easily understandable for customers, avoiding complex legal jargon.

Return policies should be communicated through multiple channels such as the website, in the checkout process, order confirmation emails, and potentially in-store signage, maintaining consistency across all platforms for a seamless customer experience. Key elements like the timeframe for returns, the condition of the product for a valid return, and any associated costs or fees should be clearly outlined to impact customer purchasing decisions.

Balancing Flexibility with Profitability

Striking a balance between flexibility and profitability is crucial in crafting an effective return policy. Full refunds can impact brand reputation and customer loyalty if mismanaged, while a customer-focused return policy can boost satisfaction, loyalty, and repeat purchases. Offering store credit instead of full refunds and selling warranties as a new revenue stream can mitigate the financial losses usually associated with flexible return policies.

Return policies must be crafted with consideration of industry and product specifics, ensuring an appropriate return window that balances customer reassurance with business practicalities. For profitability optimization, it is crucial to regularly evaluate and adjust the return policy based on consumer feedback and return data analytics.

WeSupply uses detailed analytics to empower eCommerce businesses. By understanding the reasons behind product returns, such as identifying common issues like color, quality, or size, businesses can enhance their offerings, optimize operations, and improve profit margins. Key features include identifying the most exchanged products, collecting direct feedback, and understanding the financial impact of returns. WeSupply also tracks CSAT and NPS for a data-driven approach to fine-tuning strategies and building a loyal customer base.

Considering Shipping Costs and Restocking Fees

While crafting a return policy, businesses must also consider shipping costs and restocking fees. Retailers that offer free returns and exchanges are seen as caring more for customer satisfaction, influencing customers’ purchasing decisions.

Restocking fees can change consumer behavior by making them more cautious in their shopping to avoid additional fees, while also helping businesses manage the profitability of returns. Transparently outlining return shipping costs and any restocking fees is crucial to avoid surprising customers and affecting their perception of the purchasing process as fair.

Returned items pose a risk to the company, as the items may not be resalable, may be damaged during transit, or may have been unpacked, affecting the possibility of resale and profitability.

WeSupply offers solutions that consider shipping costs and restocking fees, providing flexibility and balance in return management:

Optimize your return management with WeSupply’s flexible solutions and enhance both customer satisfaction and revenue. Book a Demo now!

Best Practices for Managing Returns

Having discussed how to formulate an effective return policy, we now shift our attention to the best practices for managing returns. This involves streamlining the return process, leveraging technology solutions, and analyzing return data to constantly improve and adapt your return policy.

Streamlining the Return Process

Optimizing the return process is crucial to alleviate customer frustration and save time. Retailers can improve return efficiency by utilizing AI chatbots for customer service queries, embracing automated messaging for status updates, and promoting self-service through online portals.

Multiple return options such as in-store, mail-in, or third-party drop-off locations, coupled with a simplification of return steps, cater to diverse customer preferences and enhance the return experience based on the purchase date.

Maintaining regular communication about return status, providing clear expectations, and offering alternatives like store credit can optimize customer satisfaction during the return process.

Combat inconvenience with proactivity & self service

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply can help you make returns easy for your customers with a beautiful, self-service solution that makes their experience easier while also providing new ways to lower costs and earn back revenue.

Leveraging Technology Solutions

Employing technology solutions can remarkably heighten the efficiency of return management. A robust returns management system can speed up the returns process, provide increased visibility, and integrate with existing business systems for operational efficiency.

Outsourcing reverse logistics to third-party logistics (3PL) partners can streamline the entire order fulfillment process, including returns, by having the 3PL inspect returned items and process refunds. Using technology solutions like automated return management systems can help manage shipping costs and restocking fees more efficiently.

Analyzing Return Data

The analysis of return data entails:

  • Gathering and scrutinizing information about returned products to comprehend the reasons for returns and their implications on business decisions

  • Return management software streamlines the return process

  • Provides analytical reports

  • Simplifies label printing for customers

  • Helps in generating statistics from collected data

  • Ultimately supporting return data analysis.

Analyzing return data yields insights to reduce returns, improve customer lifetime value, pinpoint product or service issues, and optimize inventory, contributing to a better balance between customer satisfaction and profitability. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for return analysis include total returns, total value of returns, percentage of reasons for returns, returns per courier company, and returns per country, painting a comprehensive picture of return trends and areas for improvement.

Implement an All-in-One Post Purchase Software

WeSupply offers a comprehensive solution for managing returns, focusing on efficiency and customer satisfaction:

  • Offer returns tracking to ease post-purchase anxiety and keep customers engaged with personalized deals through email and SMS notifications.

Experience the positive effects of WeSupply’s efficient solutions on your eCommerce returns process and customer satisfaction. Book a Demo now!

Case Studies: Evereve Success in Turning Returns Into Opportunities With WeSupply

The fashion industry faced challenges with a manual and inefficient returns process, lacking visibility into return data and reasons, causing operational problems and customer service issues. The goal was to enhance the return process, reducing friction to increase sales and customer loyalty. EVEREVE transformed their returns process using WeSupply’s technology, integrating with Magento and APIs like Zendesk, Celerant, Veeqo. This shift to an automated, unified system focused on proactivity, self-service, and return flexibility, improving operational understanding and balancing their return strategy while boosting customer loyalty.


In the ever-evolving ecommerce landscape, a well-crafted return policy can be a game-changer. From enhancing customer experience and encouraging loyalty, to adapting to consumer preferences and leveraging technology, the right return policy strikes a balance between customer satisfaction and business profitability. Whether it’s offering full refunds or store credit, or streamlining return processes, each decision plays a crucial role in shaping the customer’s shopping experience. As demonstrated by successful companies like Zappos and Nordstrom, a customer-focused return policy not only fosters loyalty but also fuels long-term growth. So, as you navigate the ecommerce waters, remember: a successful return policy is not just about accepting returns; it’s about returning the favor to your customers by providing them with a seamless and satisfactory shopping experience.

WeSupply is revolutionizing return policies with a self-service eCommerce returns center that empowers customers, incentivizes exchanges with instant store credit, and ensures a branded omnichannel experience. Flexible return rules cater to specific needs, backed by data-driven insights from customer return feedback. The platform simplifies returns with autogenerated QR code labels, offers tracking, and engages customers through email and SMS notifications, enhancing efficiency, satisfaction, and loyalty for eCommerce businesses.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are examples of different return policies?

Return policies can vary in terms of the return period, such as seven, 14, 30, 60, or 90 days, and some businesses may even accept returns beyond 90 days. It’s important to clearly communicate these rules to customers.

What is the standard return policy?

The standard return policy typically ranges from 15 to 30 days, with some businesses offering up to 90 days or even 365 days with a receipt. It’s important to check the specific policy of the store you’re making a purchase from to ensure clarity on return timeframes.

How can a business craft an effective return policy?

Crafting an effective return policy involves clear communication, finding a balance between flexibility and profitability, and taking into account shipping costs and restocking fees. This ensures a fair and sustainable approach for both the business and its customers.

How does WeSupply handle returns for damaged products?

WeSupply ensures a fair and considerate return process by waiving return fees for damaged products, prioritizing customer satisfaction.

Can WeSupply help me understand why my customers are returning items?

Yes, WeSupply provides insights into customer return feedback, helping you identify common reasons for returns and make informed decisions to improve product offerings and policies.

Can I tailor WeSupply's return rules to match my specific business needs?

Absolutely, WeSupply allows you to create flexible return rules to match any use case, providing a hassle-free return policy tailored to your business.

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

WeSupply Post Purchase Emails
WeSupply Post Purchase Emails

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

Jump Ahead!

In this article you'll learn:

Learn How To Create Successful Post Purchase Email Campaigns

Build an effective post-purchase email flow that helps you increase customer satisfaction and drive revenue growth!

Consumers seek the best deals on:

Related articles