Retain over 40% of your returns as exchanges! -
    • Tracking & Notifications

      Boost customer experience and reduce support tickets

      Identify and Resolve Order Issues

      Realtime order and shipment tracking

      Delivery Notifications

      Proactive order and shipping notifications

      Increase Conversion Rate

      Predictive pre-purchase estimated delivery dates

      Branded Tracking

      Self-Serivce branded order tracking

      Reduce Operational Cost

      Effortless experience delivered

      Returns & Exchanges

      Make returns profitable and delight customers

      Flexible Return Policies

      Flexibility to define any return destinations & conditions

      Self-Service Returns

      Simplify returns for your customers and team


      Incentivize exchanges over returns

      Automate Returns Management

      Returns management made easy for your team

      Returns Analytics

      Understand why your customers are returning

      In-Store and Curbside Pickup

      Unify the online and the in-store experience

      Curbside Pickup Check-in

      Hassle-free pickup experience for customers

      Pickup order management

      In-Store Dashboard to keep operations streamlined

      Unified Commerce

      In-Store and Online orders unified

      Store Locator

      Drive foot-traffic to your stores

      Tracking & Notifications

      Boost customer experience and reduce support tickets

      Identify and Resolve Order Issues

      Realtime order and shipment tracking

      Delivery Notifications

      Proactive order and shipping notifications

      Increase Conversion Rate

      Predictive pre-purchase estimated delivery dates

      Branded Tracking

      Self-Serivce branded order tracking

      Reduce Operational Cost

      Effortless experience delivered

      Returns & Exchanges

      Make returns profitable and delight customers

      Flexible Return Policies

      Flexibility to define any return destinations & conditions

      Self-Service Returns

      Simplify returns for your customers and team


      Incentivize exchanges over returns

      Automate Returns Management

      Returns management made easy for your team

      Returns Analytics

      Understand why your customers are returning

      In-Store and Curbside Pickup

      Unify the online and the in-store experience

      Curbside Pickup Check-in

      Hassle-free pickup experience for customers

      Pickup order management

      In-Store Dashboard to keep operations streamlined

      Unified Commerce

      In-Store and Online orders unified

      Store Locator

      Drive foot-traffic to your stores

      See how WeSupply works! A step-by-step trip through our functionality

  • Integrations
  • Customers
    • Help Center

      Find the answer to all your questions

      WeSupply FAQ

      Explore the most comon questions about WeSupply

      Post Purchase ROI Calculator

      Calculate the ROI that WeSupply can bring you

      FREE Website Review

      Request a no strings attached review of your current shopping experience and missed conversion opportunities

      How It Works

      Take a step by step trip through our functionality to see how we can improve your ecommerce processes.

      Blog & Guides

      Read actionable articles on how to optimize your post-purchase experience and decrease support tickets

      Case Studies

      Get inspired by stories of how our customers implemented an effortless post-purchase experience

      Behind The Brand

      A Deep Dive into Top Companies' Order Tracking & Returns Strategy

      Pre-built Return Policies

      Wondering if WeSupply is a good fit for you? Read through our use cases to see how we can help you increase conversion & improve CX!

  • Pricing

Crafting a Return Policy: Your Step-by-Step Strategy that Aligns with Your Brand

Crafting a Return Policy: Your Step-by-Step Strategy that Aligns with Your Brand

Struggling with crafting a return policy for your brand? Let this comprehensive guide demystify the process. We dive into establishing a return policy that resonates with your brand values, ensures legal compliance, and commits to customer satisfaction. Discover how to perfectly balance your rights as a seller with customer care, leading to a seamless return experience that promotes loyalty and protects your business.

Key Takeaways

  • A comprehensive return policy is integral to building customer trust, articulating clear expectations around returns and exchanges, and preventing fraud. It should transparently detail the timeframe, refund logistics, customer effort required, item eligibility, and exchange options.

  • An effective return policy can strengthen customer relationships, foster loyalty, and has been shown to increase repeat purchases and reduce cart abandonment. Businesses should design lenient and transparent policies, drawing inspiration from successful companies like Amazon and Nordstrom.

  • The development of a return policy must consider business goals, legal compliance, and simplify the return process for customers by using self-service options and efficient refund and exchange handling. Communication strategies and training for customer support teams are crucial for policy implementation.

  • WeSupply simplifies return policy management for e-commerce businesses, enhancing customer experience and operational efficiency. Key features include incentivizing exchanges, offering instant store credit, and a user-friendly returns portal. Its flexible rules, clear item conditions, QR code labels, and tracking system streamline the return process. Additionally, WeSupply’s analytics provide insights for policy refinement and business optimization, ensuring a positive return experience that aligns with your brand’s values. Get Started with WeSupply today!

Understanding the Essentials of a Return Policy

A return policy is more than just an agreement between a business and its customers. It’s a vital tool that sets expectations and helps build trust by outlining the conditions for returns, refunds, and exchanges. A well-crafted return and refund policy displays professionalism and reliability, which in turn aids in preventing fraud and enhancing customer satisfaction.

The primary elements of a return policy include:

  • The timeframe for returns

  • Monetary aspects like refunds

  • The effort required from customers

  • The scope of items eligible for return

  • Exchange options

Businesses can contribute to a positive customer experience by ensuring transparency and reducing confusion through clear outlines of these elements.

WeSupply empowers businesses in ecommerce with the flexibility to craft custom return policies, effectively managing the complexities of online logistics. This approach allows for tailored handling of various aspects such as final sale items, the duration of return windows, and the approval process for return requests. By giving businesses the control to decide these critical elements, WeSupply facilitates a more streamlined, adaptable, and efficient return management system, catering to both business needs and customer satisfaction.

The Benefits of an Effective Return Policy

A return policy is not just a set of rules; it’s an opportunity to build a strong relationship with your customers. Companies like Amazon, Zappos, and Nordstrom have shown that aligning return policies with brand values, such as offering free return shipping, can increase customer loyalty and sales retention.

The key lies in simplifying the process for consumers. Studies have shown that customers are more likely to shop again if they have a positive return experience. Moreover, lenient return policies can increase purchase rates and reduce the likelihood of returns, ultimately aiding in customer retention. Given that up to 84% of online customers review return policies before purchasing, it’s evident that an improved policy can decrease cart abandonment.

Recognizing that a straightforward return process boosts repeat purchases, WeSupply offers solutions that simplify returns, encouraging more sales while unexpectedly reducing return rates. This approach is vital as a majority of online customers consider return policies before purchasing. To see how optimizing your return policy with WeSupply can impact your ROI, explore the possibilities with our ROI Calculator.

Designing Your Return Policy: Where to Begin

Planning and preparation are essential before you start crafting your return policy. A return policy should take into account various factors, including:

  • Processing fees

  • return shipping costs

  • Staffing expenses

  • Restocking

  • shipping costs

It should also align with customer expectations and competitive benchmarks.

Let’s delve deeper into the two key aspects of this process: identifying your business goals and understanding legal considerations.

Identifying Your Goals

Your return policy should be a strategic asset that aligns with your overall business goals. After all, an effective return policy can contribute significantly to managing product returns and ensuring a high level of business performance. Misalignments in the return policy can lead to strategic issues for managers, curbing the strength of alignment between the returns management process, policy, and overall business goals.

This alignment is crucial for the successful implementation of your return policy. Aligning your policy with business goals can lead to an efficient returns process, minimized losses, and maximized customer satisfaction.

Legal Considerations

Complying with legal requirements is a non-negotiable aspect of crafting a return policy. Businesses must ensure their policies are compliant with country-specific and state-specific laws to avoid violating consumer protection laws. Federal law does not obligate merchants to provide refunds based on buyer’s remorse, but state laws may dictate conditions under which returns must be accepted or refunds issued.

These legal requirements can vary significantly, making it necessary to accommodate regional exceptions within return policies. A coherent return policy that complies with these legal requirements not only helps to avoid legal penalties but also fosters customer loyalty by setting clear expectations. Hence, seeking professional legal advice is necessary when crafting your return policy.

Optimizing Returns with WeSupply: Smart, Flexible, and Fair Return Policy Design

WeSupply offers an innovative approach to designing return policies that are both fair and business-friendly:

  • Flexible Return Rules for Every Scenario: Recognizing the diversity in return scenarios, WeSupply enables you to create adaptable policies.


    • Smart Return Rules: Tailor policies to match all item attributes perfectly.

    • Customizable Conditions: Offer free return shipping with fully customizable logics.

    • Intelligent Dispositions: Streamline sorting of physical returns with smart dispositions.

This dynamic approach by WeSupply allows businesses to craft return policies that align with both their operational needs and customer expectations, ensuring a smooth and efficient return process. Ready to revolutionize your return process? Book a demo with WeSupply today and discover the power of smart returns!

Crafting Clear Terms for Returns and Exchanges

Upon identifying your business goals and understanding the legal landscape, you can commence crafting clear terms for returns and exchanges. This will involve specifying the return window and detailing the conditions under which items can be returned or exchanged.

Specifying the Return Window

One of the first things customers look for in a return policy is the return window. Clearly stating this timeframe is key to setting accurate expectations. Generally, return policies establish a return window of 30 to 60 days post-purchase, within which customers can return their items.

Disclosing the exact return window timeframe helps avoid situations where customers attempt to return items long after the purchase date. For items accompanied by a gift receipt, retailers often provide an extended return window to benefit the gift recipients. Some retailers, like American Eagle, even allow returns at any time with receipt retention, showcasing their generous return windows.

WeSupply offers a clear solution to the common confusion surrounding return windows in e-commerce. With flexible options, it eliminates ambiguity for both customers and staff. You can set return windows based on various criteria, such as order date, fulfillment date, or delivery date. Additionally, WeSupply allows for holiday-specific return windows and customization according to product SKU, type, or tag. This versatility ensures a hassle-free return experience, tailored to both business needs and customer convenience.

Detailing Item Conditions

In addition to the return window, specifying the conditions for returning or exchanging items is of utmost importance. A return policy should clearly state that items can only be returned or exchanged if they are:

  • unopened

  • unused

  • in original packaging

  • in the same condition as when purchased

Stipulating these condition requirements in the refund policy helps prevent returns of merchandise that cannot be resold, ultimately safeguarding your business’s profitability. The policy may also specify conditions under which items would only qualify for partial refunds or exchanges, offering flexibility to accommodate various product return scenarios.

For specific items such as custom-made products or software, the policy should clearly state these are generally non-refundable, with any exceptions for a full refund clearly outlined.

WeSupply streamlines return policy compliance by clarifying which items are eligible for return or exchange. This clarity helps customers understand their options, leading to fewer ineligible returns. With WeSupply, there’s no confusion:

  • Non-Returnable Items: Customers can easily identify which items cannot be returned, eliminating uncertainty and reducing back-and-forth communication.


    • Final Sale Products

    • Non re-sellable items

    • Items outside of the return window

    • Block listed customers

This feature ensures a smoother return process, enhancing customer satisfaction while maintaining efficient return management. Take the first step towards a seamless return process – Get started with WeSupply today and transform your customer experience!

Streamlining the Returns Process

Upon crafting the terms for returns and exchanges, your focus should shift to streamlining the returns process. This involves making the return process as easy as possible for your customers, which not only enhances customer convenience and satisfaction but also improves your business’s efficiency.

We’ll now focus on how to simplify the steps for customers and handle refunds and exchanges efficiently.

Simplified Steps for Customers

One of the key elements of a streamlined return process is making it easy for customers to initiate free returns. Implementing a self-service return and refund platform, for instance, allows customers to initiate returns easily. By using an online return portal, customers can print their own return shipping labels, saving time for both the customer and business operations.

Making the exchange process easy with pre-paid return labels or free return shipping encourages customers to opt for exchanges over returns. A self-service customer portal for requesting and redeeming store credit can enhance the customer experience and reduce the workload on customer service teams. The return initiation process should include clear steps with relevant page links for the customer’s convenience.

Handling Refunds and Exchanges Efficiently

While simplifying the return process for customers is crucial, handling refunds and exchanges efficiently on the business’s end carries equal importance. Implementing automated return tracking enables customers to monitor their returns and reduces inquiries, optimizing the refund or exchange process. An integrated Point of Sale system can enhance the efficiency of processing returns and managing inventory updates in real-time.

Automating reverse logistics, like storage and inventory management, is vital for handling refunds and exchanges with speed and accuracy. Clearly stating the conditions required for returns, such as the need for items to be in original packaging and in good condition, streamlines the refund process. Store credits or gift cards offer a refund option that retains revenue within the company, especially when purchase details are difficult to confirm. Once the returned item is received, refunds are expedited by utilizing the original payment method, ensuring a smooth transaction reverse. However, it’s important to be transparent about any restocking fees or return fees that may be necessary for expensive or complex products.

Streamlining Returns with WeSupply: Enhancing Efficiency and Customer Loyalty

WeSupply streamlines the returns process, enhancing customer loyalty and reducing return rates through its key features:

  • Returns Tracking: Provide customers with easy access to track their returns, alleviating post-purchase anxiety.

  • Post-Purchase Notifications: Keep customers engaged with high open-rate email and SMS updates, offering personalized deals to encourage repeat business.

These features collectively contribute to a more efficient, customer-centric returns process with WeSupply. Discover the simplicity of returns with WeSupply. Book a demo now and elevate your return process!

Combat inconvenience with proactivity & self service

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply can help you make returns easy for your customers with a beautiful, self-service solution that makes their experience easier while also providing new ways to lower costs and earn back revenue.

Case Study: Evereve's Efficient Returns Strategy with WeSupply

Facing increased online returns during COVID-19, Evereve, a retail company with over 93 boutiques, revolutionized its returns process by adopting WeSupply’s technology. This move automated returns, streamlined data handling, and provided greater process visibility. The new approach, focusing on proactivity, self-service, and return flexibility, significantly reduced customer service burdens and enhanced the customer experience. The implementation led to cost savings, improved return efficiency, and bolstered employee productivity, effectively transforming returns from a challenge into a growth opportunity. Discover how Evereve redefined customer returns for success — Read the full case study now!

Communicating Your Policy to Customers

The next step in crafting an effective return policy is communicating it to your customers. Building trust and ensuring a seamless customer experience requires consistent communication of the return policy across all channels like websites, mobile apps, and customer service.

Let’s explore the best practices for website placement strategies and customer support team training.

Website Placement Strategies

Having your return policy visible on your website is crucial in setting the right expectations before customers make a purchase. To ensure customers are aware of it before making a purchase, the return policy should be included in multiple visible places on the website, including:

  • The footer

  • Banners

  • FAQ page

  • Order confirmation emails

  • Product pages

Effective placement of the return policy can lead to a significant reduction in customer inquiries, saving time and resources for your business. Chubbies, an online clothing retailer, is an excellent example of effective policy placement. They include return questions in their website chat window and offer a one-click process to initiate a return.

Customer Support Team Training

Implementing your return policy effectively requires a well-trained customer support team. Staff who are knowledgeable about the return policy can provide exceptional customer service during the returns process, contributing to a positive customer experience. This training should include a thorough understanding of your store’s return and exchange policies, including:

  • eligibility criteria

  • time frame

  • required documentation

  • refund methods

  • any exceptions

Support teams need to be knowledgeable about:

  • How to initiate a return or exchange process

  • The specifics of what items can be returned or exchanged, and under what conditions

  • They should have access to a written manual, digital resource, or cheat sheet that summarizes the return policy’s key points for quick reference and accuracy

  • Regular updates on any changes to the return policy or special promotions that might affect the handling of returns and exchanges are also crucial.

Additionally, training customer service representatives to skillfully suggest exchanges and showcase alternative products can lead to a higher exchange rate, while adhering to the company’s exchange policy.

Incentivizing Positive Return Behavior

Once you have streamlined the return process and trained your team effectively, the next step involves incentivizing positive return behavior. This involves encouraging customers to choose exchanges over refunds and offering store credit.

Next, let’s explore methods to encourage exchanges over refunds and the advantages of offering store credit.

Encouraging Exchanges Over Refunds

Encourage customers to choose exchanges over refunds is a potent strategy to retain revenue. Offering loyalty points, rewards, or exclusive offers specifically for customers choosing an exchange over a refund can boost the likelihood of retaining revenue through exchanges. Implementing a clear return and exchange policy can also contribute to this goal.

An ‘instant exchange’ process and targeted marketing campaigns can educate customers on the benefits of exchanges, reducing wait times, and promoting a more favorable option over refunds. Highlighting environmental advantages, such as a lower carbon footprint due to fewer shipments, can resonate with eco-conscious customers, leading them to prefer exchanges.

Organizing in-store exchange events can reinforce brand loyalty and encourage exchange over refund choices, leading to repeat business. Furthermore, promoting product upgrades can turn a return into an opportunity for increased sales.

Offering Store Credit

Offering store credit is another effective strategy to maintain customer connection and encourage future purchases. More than half of customers who receive store credit redeem it, and the money stays with the store whether it is redeemed or not.

Customers who receive store credit are 50% more likely to buy again than those who receive a regular refund, enhancing customer loyalty. In fact, customers often spend at least $20 extra per order when they redeem their store credit, thus increasing average order value and overall revenue.

With the right incentives, such as bonus credit, you can offer store credit more attractive to customers than cash refunds.

Incentivizing Exchanges with WeSupply: Transforming Returns into Opportunities

WeSupply incentivizes positive return behavior by encouraging exchanges over refunds, transforming potential losses into opportunities:

  • Convert Returns into Exchanges: Enable customers to exchange returned items for any product, the same item, or items of equal or higher value.

  • Incentivize Exchanges: Boost sales and average order value by rewarding customers who choose instant store credit.


    • Offer instant store credit for exchanges.

    • Redirect customers to the product catalog post-return initiation.

    • Promote exchange incentives and credit coupons.

  • Refund to Store Credit: Encourage repeat shopping and foster trust by offering refunds as store credits, gift cards, or coupon codes.
  • Seamless Exchange Experience: Ensure a smooth exchange process by directing customers back to your website, providing the feel of regular shopping.

WeSupply’s approach not only saves sales but also enhances customer loyalty, making the return process a positive aspect of the shopping experience. Turn returns into wins with WeSupply. Book a demo now and redefine your returns strategy!

Incentivize exchanges over returns

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply can help you save sales through exchanges and boost the average order value using instant store credit.

Adjusting Your Policy Based on Feedback

After implementing your return policy, you should monitor its effectiveness and make necessary adjustments based on feedback. Analyzing the reasons behind product returns and customer feedback can highlight operational issues like incorrect size or color, leading to improvements in product descriptions or quality control.

Monitoring returns data provides insights into customer behavior and product quality, informing data-driven decisions to enhance return policies and customer lifetime value. Regular updates to the return policy are crucial to reflect brand values, account for changes in products or services, and stay in line with evolving customer behaviors. Implementing return metrics can be vital for managing exchanges and refunds effectively.

WeSupply leverages detailed analytics to empower eCommerce businesses to refine their return policies based on insightful customer feedback. By understanding the reasons behind product returns, such as identifying the most returned items and discerning specific issues like color, quality, or size, businesses can enhance their product offerings. Key features include identifying the most exchanged products, collecting direct product feedback, and understanding the financial impact of returns and exchanges. Additionally, WeSupply’s logistics analytics underscore the importance of a data-driven approach. By tracking CSAT and NPS, businesses can continuously fine-tune their strategies and adapt to customer needs, ultimately leading to a more delightful and loyal customer base.

Implementing a Return Management Solution

Once you’ve made adjustments to your policy based on feedback, a return management solution like WeSupply can be implemented to maintain the efficacy of your return policy. Automated return management systems uphold your return policy and free up your team for other tasks, enhancing overall efficiency and customer satisfaction.

A return management system allows businesses to:

  • Manage returns quickly and cost-effectively

  • Enable customers to initiate returns

  • Generate prepaid labels

  • Restock inventory efficiently

By implementing a return management system, businesses can streamline their return processes, improve the customer experience, and gain valuable business intelligence for inventory management and issue resolution.

Creating a Positive Narrative Around Returns

Navigating the complexities of crafting an effective return policy requires creating a positive narrative around returns. This involves utilizing narrative marketing strategies, such as personifying the problem and portraying the return process as a customer’s journey to satisfaction.

Creating a positive narrative around returns by focusing on the customer and their needs, rather than the product, portrays returns as a customer-centric service which can improve the customer’s life. Advertise customer-centric return policies as ‘free,’ ‘easy,’ and ‘no-hassle’ to enhance brand sentiment and loyalty, ensuring that over 90% of consumers who value transparency see the brand as trustworthy and customer-focused.

WeSupply transforms the narrative around returns into a positive aspect of the customer journey. By streamlining the return process and offering clear, customer-friendly policies, it turns potential negative experiences into opportunities for enhanced customer satisfaction and loyalty. WeSupply ensures that returns are not seen as a setback but as a chance to reinforce trust and build a stronger relationship with customers. This approach not only improves the customer experience but also positions returns as a valuable touchpoint in the customer lifecycle.


In conclusion, crafting a return policy that aligns with your brand is a multifaceted process that involves understanding the essentials of a return policy, designing it to fit your business goals, communicating it effectively to customers, and incentivizing positive return behavior. With a well-crafted return policy, not only can you increase customer loyalty and sales retention, but you can also turn returns into opportunities for new profits. After all, a return policy isn’t just a set of rules; it’s a tool for building a strong relationship with your customers.

WeSupply streamlines crafting a return policy aligned with your brand, blending customer satisfaction and business efficiency. It encourages exchanges over refunds, offers instant store credit, and features a branded returns portal for enhanced loyalty. The platform provides flexible return rules, clear item condition guidelines, and effortless return processes with QR codes and tracking. Additionally, WeSupply’s analytics tools allow for policy adjustments based on customer feedback, optimizing business operations and profit margins. This approach transforms returns into a positive, data-driven aspect of the customer journey, making WeSupply a vital tool for e-commerce businesses.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an acceptable return policy?

An acceptable return policy typically includes a time frame of 15 to 30 days for returns, but some businesses may offer longer periods, such as 90 days or even up to 365 days with a purchase receipt.

How do you abuse a return policy?

Abusing a return policy involves purchasing two items, switching their packaging, and then returning the cheaper item as the higher-priced item to get more money back. This practice is considered fraudulent.

What is WeSupply's approach to crafting a return policy?

WeSupply helps e-commerce businesses create return policies that are aligned with brand values, focusing on customer satisfaction and operational efficiency. It offers flexible solutions for managing returns, exchanges, and refunds.

How does WeSupply incentivize positive return behavior?

The platform encourages exchanges over refunds and offers instant store credit to retain sales. This approach helps in reducing return rates while enhancing customer loyalty.

Can WeSupply's return policy be customized for different products?

Yes, WeSupply allows for flexible return rules based on various criteria such as product type, condition, and return windows, enabling customization according to specific product needs.

How does WeSupply handle item conditions in returns?

It provides clear guidelines on which items are eligible for return or exchange, including final sale products, non-resellable items, and items outside the return window, thus reducing confusion and ineligible returns.

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

WeSupply Post Purchase Emails
WeSupply Post Purchase Emails

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

Jump Ahead!

In this article you'll learn:

Learn How To Create Successful Post Purchase Email Campaigns

Build an effective post-purchase email flow that helps you increase customer satisfaction and drive revenue growth!

Related articles