The Return Season is here! Retain over 40% of your returns as exchanges! - Learn More
    • Tracking & Notifications

      Boost customer experience and reduce support tickets

      Identify and Resolve Order Issues

      Realtime order and shipment tracking

      Delivery Notifications

      Proactive order and shipping notifications

      Increase Conversion Rate

      Predictive pre-purchase estimated delivery dates

      Branded Tracking

      Self-Serivce branded order tracking

      Reduce Operational Cost

      Effortless experience delivered

      Returns & Exchanges

      Make returns profitable and delight customers

      Flexible Return Policies

      Flexibility to define any return destinations & conditions

      Self-Service Returns

      Simplify returns for your customers and team

      Exchanges

      Incentivize exchanges over returns

      Automate Returns Management

      Returns management made easy for your team

      Returns Analytics

      Understand why your customers are returning

      In-Store and Curbside Pickup

      Unify the online and the in-store experience

      Curbside Pickup Check-in

      Hassle-free pickup experience for customers

      Pickup order management

      In-Store Dashboard to keep operations streamlined

      Unified Commerce

      In-Store and Online orders unified

      Store Locator

      Drive foot-traffic to your stores

  • Integrations
  • Customers
    • Help Center

      Find the answer to all your questions

      WeSupply FAQ

      Explore the most comon questions about WeSupply

      Post Purchase ROI Calculator

      Calculate the ROI that WeSupply can bring you

      FREE Website Review

      Request a no strings attached review of your current shopping experience and missed conversion opportunities

      Blog & Guides

      Read actionable articles on how to optimize your post-purchase experience and decrease support tickets

      Case Studies

      Get inspired by stories of how our customers implemented an effortless post-purchase experience

      Behind The Brand

      A Deep Dive into Top Companies' Order Tracking & Returns Strategy

      Pre-built Return Policies

      Wondering if WeSupply is a good fit for you? Read through our use cases to see how we can help you increase conversion & improve CX!

  • Pricing

Sign in

Prevent Wardrobing Return Fraud: 5 Effective eCommerce Strategies

WeSupply preventing wardrobing

Are customers returning worn merchandise and impacting your bottom line? Learn how to prevent wardrobing return fraud with our five tailored eCommerce strategies to safeguard your retail business.

Key Takeaways

  • Wardrobing return fraud, where customers buy, use, and then return items as new, significantly impacts retailers financially by causing lost sales, increased processing costs, and markdowns on fraudulently returned items.

     

  • Combating wardrobing in e-commerce requires strategic measures such as clear return policies, thorough inspections, use of specialized anti-wardrobing tags, and offering store credit instead of cash refunds to deter fraudulent behavior.

     

  • Advancements in technology, like the implementation of digital tools and predictive models, are essential for monitoring, managing, and preventing wardrobing and other types of return fraud, ensuring retailers can stay ahead of evolving fraudulent practices.

     

  • WeSupply combats wardrobing return fraud through strict pre-built return policies and automated returns management. By leveraging a branded returns portal and store credit incentives, WeSupply ensures efficient handling of returns, fraud detection, and enhanced customer satisfaction. Get started with WeSupply to protect your business and improve returns management.

Introduction to Wardrobing Return Fraud

It’s estimated that around 10.7% of returned online purchases are fraudulent, with fashion retailers being hit the hardest by returns fraud. A considerable part of this fraud is wardrobing, where customers buy items, use them, and then return them as new. This crime is not victimless. It is damaging retailers financially and hurting their operations.

As a retailer, one may wonder how to identify wardrobing, understand its implications, and protect their business from this growing menace. The following sections will shed some light on these aspects.

Understanding the Scope and Definition of Wardrobing

Wardrobing, as a type of return fraud, is an abuse of lenient return policies. Customers buy items such as clothing, wear them (often with tags hidden), and then return them for a full refund. E-commerce has made wardrobing more accessible due to the anonymity of online shopping and return processes.

While this may seem like a clever loophole to some, it’s a significant problem for retailers. Not only does this result in financial losses from reduced profits and markdowns, but it also causes additional costs for processing, restocking, and evaluating resell-ability of fraudulently returned items, leading to lost sales.

Economic Impact on Retailers and the eCommerce Landscape

From the surface, the economic impact of wardrobing on retailers might seem limited to refunds. But dig deeper, and there’s more to the story. Increased processing and labor costs, lost revenue from returned used inventory, and additional capital required to replace merchandise, all add up, causing a significant dent in a retailer’s financial health.

The anonymity of online returns has emboldened consumers to return worn items without having to explain, thus increasing the incidence of wardrobing in the eCommerce sector. Handling these fraudulent returns means higher labor costs and complex restocking procedures leading to inventory management issues. If that wasn’t enough, there’s an environmental cost too, with returned merchandise ending up in landfills.

Who Engages in Wardrobing and Why?

While it’s easy to point fingers at ‘unethical customers’, the reality is more complex. It’s not just about people wanting to cheat the system. There are various reasons why customers resort to wardrobing, ranging from financial constraints to social pressures.

Even social media influencers often engage in wardrobing to create content for their online image, returning the items once they have served their purpose. In the following sections, we’ll explore the demographics and motivations that fuel wardrobing.

Demographics and Psychological Motivations Behind Wardrobing

The pressure to maintain a certain image or lifestyle, especially prevalent among influencers, can motivate wardrobing behaviors. Clothing choices are essential in shaping first impressions, which includes inferences about the wearer’s:

  • social categories

  • cognitive states

  • status

  • aesthetic tastes

However, the complexity, cultural dependence, and variability of clothing’s psychological meaning have made it a challenging subject for research aimed at uncovering psychological universals. Despite these challenges, it’s clear that wardrobing is not merely a financial issue but also a psychological and social one.

Economic Circumstances and Social Influences Contributing to Fraud

Economic circumstances also play a significant role in wardrobing fraud. Consumers under financial strain may exhibit unethical behavior to save money. The trend of posting daily outfits on social media platforms like Instagram encourages people to engage in wardrobing.

Moreover, the desire to keep up with fashion trends and avoid outfit repetition can motivate people to engage in wardrobing. This shows that wardrobing is not just an individual’s problem but a societal one, influenced by broader economic and social trends.

Legal and Ethical Considerations of Wardrobing

Wardrobing poses not just economic challenges but also legal and ethical dilemmas. It makes up approximately 70% of all fraudulent returns in the retail industry, with an annual cost of $23.2 billion. But the impact goes beyond financial losses.

Ethical issues in eCommerce returns involve environmental impact, fairness of return policies, and employee welfare. The subsequent sections will thoroughly examine these aspects.

Analyzing the Legality and Ethical Dilemmas in Return Fraud

Wardrobing is often perceived by consumers as a victimless crime and difficult to legally pursue, creating a false reality. It breaches merchant policies and raises ethical concerns. While proving a ‘misrepresentation of a material fact’ by someone who knows or believes it to be false is often hard, legal cases of wardrobing often revolve around this concept.

However, the primary response to wardrobing is not usually legal action but refusal of a refund if the store suspects an item has been worn. This highlights the complexities of tackling wardrobing from a legal perspective.

Balancing Consumer Rights with Retailer Protections

While tackling wardrobing, it’s crucial to balance consumer rights with retailer protections. Measures like anti-wardrobing tags can prevent wardrobing while also respecting consumer rights.

Retailers also need to establish clear return policies to deter wardrobing practices. However, these measures should not compromise the consumer’s right to return items. This balance is crucial in maintaining not just legal compliance but also customer trust and loyalty.

Strategic Framework to Combat Wardrobing

So, how can retailers combat wardrobing? A strategic approach should involve a combination of:

  • Clear return policies

  • Thorough inspections

  • Specialized tags to identify wear

  • Providing store credit as a refund option

These strategies not only make wardrobing less convenient but also minimize its financial impacts. In the following sections, we will explore these strategies in detail.

Establishing Clear Return Policies with Strict Requirements

The first line of defense against wardrobing is a clear and strict return policy. This policy should detail:

  • The types of returns accepted

  • Items eligible for return

  • Any fees such as restocking or return shipping

  • The time frame for initiating returns

  • The expected timeline for processing the return.

Prominent display of return policies on:

  • Websites

  • Invoices

  • Receipts

  • Product packaging

helps ensure customers are clearly aware of the terms and conditions governing returns. Not only does this set clear expectations but also deters potential fraudsters.

WeSupply’s Pre-built Return Policies offer a strategic framework to combat wardrobing by establishing clear and strict return policies. Key features include:

  • No Returns on Used Products: Enhances quality control by making used items non-returnable, ensuring customer satisfaction and maintaining product standards.
  • Specific SKU Restrictions: Improves inventory control by designating certain SKUs as non-returnable, aligning product strategy with return policies.

With these measures in place, WeSupply’s Pre-built Return Policies empower businesses to enhance inventory management, maintain product quality, and protect profitability. Book a demo today to see how these policies can revolutionize your return management strategy!

Create custom return policies

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply can help you take control of returns by creating custom policies to handle them all easily. You get to decide how you want to handle final sale items, return window lengths, return request approvals, and more.

The Importance of a Strong Inspection Process in Reverse Logistics

A meticulous inspection of returned items is critical in identifying and preventing wardrobing, as well as addressing buyer’s remorse. Retailers should look for signs of wear, tampering, or stolen or counterfeit items before issuing refunds.

This, however, means higher labor costs and complex restocking procedures leading to inventory management issues. But these costs are a small price to pay compared to the financial losses from wardrobing.

WeSupply’s Automated Returns Management system enhances the strategic framework to combat wardrobing by emphasizing a robust inspection process in reverse logistics. By enabling customers to upload images and describe issues directly on the branded returns page, the system streamlines communication and captures essential product condition details. This functionality not only eliminates the need for lengthy email exchanges but also enriches the quality control process. Each return is meticulously inspected based on predefined quality criteria, and warehouse staff can annotate specific observations, ensuring that only resalable items are restocked. This comprehensive approach to handling returns significantly improves inventory management and customer satisfaction.

Utilizing Return Portals for Enhanced Fraud Detection

The use of return portals can assist in verifying the state of returned items and reducing the incidence of wardrobing. These portals can be enhanced with features such as image uploads to allow retailers to verify the condition of returned items and more effectively decide on the approval or denial of returns.

Moreover, online return portals can:

  • Automatically verify purchases before a return is created, reducing the risk of fraudulent returns

  • Provide an additional layer of security

  • Improve the customer return experience.

WeSupply empowers businesses to effectively combat wardrobing through its branded returns portal, which not only enhances customer loyalty but also bolsters fraud detection. By providing a fully customizable, user-friendly interface, businesses can offer a seamless, branded post-purchase experience with intuitive return rules that help identify suspicious return patterns. This tailored approach ensures better fraud detection while maintaining a positive customer experience, aligning brand identity with strategic anti-fraud measures.

The Role of Store Credit in Deterring Return Fraud

Offering store credit instead of cash refunds can be an effective strategy to discourage wardrobing. It ensures that customers continue to engage with the retailer for future purchases.

Moreover, customers choosing store credit over cash refunds have several benefits for the retailer:

  • They are more likely to make additional purchases, thereby generating additional revenue.

  • This approach deters wardrobing.

  • It encourages customer loyalty.

WeSupply’s strategic approach to combating wardrobing leverages store credit to deter return fraud effectively. By incentivizing exchanges with instant store credit, customers are encouraged to reinvest in the product catalog, boosting sales and increasing average order value. The option to refund via store credit, gift card, or coupon code further fosters customer loyalty, reducing fraudulent returns while strengthening customer trust and encouraging repeat purchases.

Technological Interventions and Anti-Wardrobing Measures

The battle against wardrobing cannot be won without technological interventions. From anti-wardrobing tags to digital tools for managing returns, technology plays a crucial role in preventing wardrobing and other types of return fraud.

The following sections will delve into these technological interventions and their respective impacts.

Implementing Anti-Wardrobing Tags and Their Impact

Anti-wardrobing tags, like the 360 ID Tag, offer the following benefits:

  • Add a layer of security against counterfeit product switches and price tag alterations

  • Designed to be practical and affordable

  • Can be applied without damaging the merchandise.

Anti-wardrobing tags are designed to discourage return fraud by being difficult to remove and reattach without evidence of tampering. This not only protects the retailer but also sets a clear deterrent for potential fraudsters, thanks to the tamper evident security seal.

Leveraging Digital Tools to Monitor and Manage Returns

Digital tools can enhance the management of returns by:

  • Providing real-time tracking of inventory

  • Connecting upstream manufacturing with downstream sales for demand forecasting

  • Reducing errors through automation and accurate recording.

Moreover, businesses can use automated returns authorization systems to:

  • Validate the eligibility of returns through technology

  • Minimize the need for manual processing

  • Improve customer satisfaction

  • Streamline the return process

  • Detect and prevent fraudulent returns

WeSupply’s Automated Returns Management system leverages advanced digital tools to enhance technological interventions and anti-wardrobing measures. Key features include:

  • Speed up Returns Process: Simplify customer returns through self-service, eliminating the need for support tickets or phone calls.
  • Streamline the Returns Process: Automatically apply specific restocking fees, return policies, and detect fraud, reducing customer emails and streamlining refunds.

  • Reduce Human Errors: Automate returnable product validation, restocking fee calculations, and return label generation to minimize errors.

Enhancing the Customer Return Experience

While combating wardrobing, it’s crucial not to compromise the customer return experience. A positive return experience not only builds customer loyalty but also encourages ethical shopping habits, reducing wardrobing occurrences.

To achieve this, retailers need to communicate return policies clearly, monitor customer returns, and set reasonable time limits and conditions for returns. The subsequent sections will thoroughly examine these aspects.

Monitoring Customer Returns and Managing Suspicious Activities

Monitoring customer returns and managing suspicious activities is key in preventing wardrobing. Retailers should track customer behaviors and flag suspicious activities, such as identifying serial returners and banning them if necessary.

Digital tools can also help in detecting return fraud and preventing other forms of return fraud. For instance, e-commerce sites can monitor inconsistencies in order data, such as mismatched zip codes and cities, or the IP address of the shopper not matching their email address.

WeSupply’s Returns Analytics empowers businesses to enhance the customer return experience by offering deep insights into return patterns. With detailed analytics, companies can identify the most frequently returned products and understand the reasons behind these returns, allowing them to address issues proactively. By pinpointing serial returners and monitoring suspicious activities, WeSupply helps reduce the return rate through actionable insights, while comprehensive data available in BigQuery ensures a data-driven approach to optimizing return policies and customer satisfaction.

Setting Time Limits and Conditions for Returns

Setting time limits and specific conditions for returns can reduce the occurrence of wardrobing by making the practice less convenient for customers. Retailers can set a time limit for returns and specify the condition that returned products need to be in, such as unused and in original packaging, to qualify for a return.

However, it’s critical that these limits and conditions are communicated clearly and prominently to customers, to avoid any confusion or misunderstanding.

WeSupply’s Pre-built Return Policies streamline the customer return experience by providing clear guidelines on time limits and conditions for returns. These predefined rules offer transparency and consistency, ensuring customers understand the return process while helping businesses enforce fair and strategic policies. This clarity not only enhances customer satisfaction but also reduces the potential for abuse, ultimately fostering trust and efficiency in the return experience.

Future Directions in Combating eCommerce Fraud

As e-commerce continues to grow, so does the threat of wardrobing and other types of return fraud. Retailers need to be proactive in combating fraud, moving away from reactive strategies to more customer-centric approaches that are integrated and continuously evolving.

Predictive analytics is increasingly playing a significant role in combating eCommerce fraud. Organizations are leveraging it to stay ahead of fraudsters and protect their operations.

Predictive Models and Emerging Trends in Retail Fraud Prevention

Predictive models, using artificial intelligence and machine learning, are essential for identifying and reacting to new types of eCommerce fraud. They help mitigate the financial impact of fraud by enabling businesses to take action early and maintain customer trust.

However, these models need to be continually updated to keep pace with evolving fraud patterns. As fraudsters develop new methods to circumvent business systems, businesses need to stay one step ahead.

Adapting to Evolving Consumer Behaviors and Technological Advances

Adapting to changing consumer behaviors and technological advances is also crucial for effective return fraud prevention. Retailers are introducing advanced technologies, such as artificial intelligence and machine learning, to bridge the gap between online and in-store shopping experiences and better understand customer needs.

Moreover, with consumers prioritizing convenience and eco-friendliness, retailers are offering more diverse, convenient, and environmentally friendly products. This not only meets customer expectations but also builds trust, reducing the likelihood of fraudulent behaviors like wardrobing. According to the National Retail Federation, this trend is becoming increasingly important in the industry.

Conclusion: Building Resilience Against Wardrobing in eCommerce

Building resilience against wardrobing in eCommerce involves a combination of:

  • Clear return policies

  • Stringent inspections

  • Advanced technology

  • A keen understanding of customer behaviors

Wardrobing extends beyond being a financial problem for retailers, encompassing complexity in psychology, economics, and technology.

The future of eCommerce fraud prevention hinges on predictive models, the evolution of consumer behaviors, and advancements in technology. In order to safeguard their businesses and customers, retailers must remain agile, continually adapt their strategies, and stay a step ahead of fraudsters.

Future Steps for Retailers to Enhance Fraud Prevention Measures

Moving forward, retailers need to continuously adapt and enhance their fraud prevention measures to combat those who commit return fraud. This includes using return portals that collect information about return reasons, request photo evidence, and set eligibility conditions.

Moreover, vigilance is key. Retailers need to conduct thorough inspections of returned items and monitor customer records for abnormal patterns. This proactive approach to combating wardrobing not only protects their business but also builds customer trust and loyalty.

Summary

In conclusion, wardrobing return fraud is a growing menace affecting the eCommerce industry. It’s a complex issue, involving legal, ethical, and psychological aspects. Retailers need to adopt a mix of clear return policies, stringent inspections, specialized tags, and store credit as a refund option to deter wardrobing. Technological advances and predictive models can help stay ahead of fraudsters. However, in all these measures, it’s crucial to balance consumer rights with retailer protections and enhance the customer return experience to encourage ethical shopping habits.

WeSupply offers comprehensive solutions to prevent wardrobing return fraud through its robust suite of return management tools. With pre-built return policies that enforce strict conditions on used, personalized, and sale items, businesses can maintain quality control and protect profitability. Automated Returns Management improves reverse logistics by enabling thorough inspections, streamlining communications, and setting predefined quality criteria for returns. A branded returns portal enhances customer loyalty while identifying suspicious return patterns, and the use of store credit deters fraudulent activity by encouraging reinvestment in the product catalog. With digital tools for monitoring returns and actionable insights from Returns Analytics, WeSupply equips businesses with the framework to handle returns efficiently and maintain customer satisfaction. Get started with WeSupply to secure your business against return fraud while optimizing the customer return experience.

Speed up returns process

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply’s self-service returns makes it super easy for your customers to return anything, anytime – without needing to submit customer support tickets or call in!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is wardrobing return fraud?

Wardrobing return fraud occurs when customers buy clothing, wear it, and then return it for a refund, taking advantage of generous return policies. It’s a form of return fraud that exploits lenient return policies.

How does wardrobing impact retailers?

Wardrobing negatively impacts retailers by leading to financial losses through reduced profits, increased markdowns, and additional processing and restocking costs.

How can retailers combat wardrobing?

To combat wardrobing, retailers should implement clear return policies, conduct thorough inspections of returned items, use anti-wardrobing tags, and offer store credit instead of cash refunds. This helps to deter customers from purchasing items for short-term use and returning them after.

How does WeSupply help prevent wardrobing return fraud?

WeSupply combats wardrobing return fraud by implementing strict pre-built return policies that establish clear guidelines on returns for used, personalized, and sale items. This helps maintain quality control and profitability by setting conditions that prevent the misuse of return policies.

How do WeSupply's automated returns systems contribute to combating wardrobing?

The Automated Returns Management system streamlines returns through robust inspections, efficient communication, and predefined quality criteria. This process identifies suspicious returns and enhances reverse logistics, reducing the chance of fraudulent activities.

How does Returns Analytics support anti-fraud measures?

Returns Analytics provides insights into return patterns, helping businesses identify frequently returned products and reasons behind returns. This data-driven approach pinpoints serial returners, monitors suspicious activities, and helps businesses proactively adjust return policies to prevent fraud.

Does WeSupply have an official Shopify App?

Yes, WeSupply does have an official Shopify App. You can download and begin to integrate it with your Shopify store.

Does WeSupply have an official Magento extension?

Yes, WeSupply has an official extension for Magento. The WeSupply x Magento integration allows for automating order tracking experiences, reducing customer inquiries, automating shipping email and SMS notifications, and providing a fully branded order tracking experience

Does WeSupply have an official BigCommerce App?

Yes, WeSupply has an official BigCommerce App. You can integrate WeSupply with your BigCommerce store to improve your post-purchase customer experience.

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

WeSupply Post Purchase Emails
WeSupply Post Purchase Emails

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

Jump Ahead!

In this article you'll learn:

Learn How To Create Successful Post Purchase Email Campaigns

Build an effective post-purchase email flow that helps you increase customer satisfaction and drive revenue growth!

Consumers seek the best deals on:

Related articles