The Return Season is here! Retain over 40% of your returns as exchanges! - Learn More
    • Tracking & Notifications

      Boost customer experience and reduce support tickets

      Identify and Resolve Order Issues

      Realtime order and shipment tracking

      Delivery Notifications

      Proactive order and shipping notifications

      Increase Conversion Rate

      Predictive pre-purchase estimated delivery dates

      Branded Tracking

      Self-Serivce branded order tracking

      Reduce Operational Cost

      Effortless experience delivered

      Returns & Exchanges

      Make returns profitable and delight customers

      Flexible Return Policies

      Flexibility to define any return destinations & conditions

      Self-Service Returns

      Simplify returns for your customers and team


      Incentivize exchanges over returns

      Automate Returns Management

      Returns management made easy for your team

      Returns Analytics

      Understand why your customers are returning

      In-Store and Curbside Pickup

      Unify the online and the in-store experience

      Curbside Pickup Check-in

      Hassle-free pickup experience for customers

      Pickup order management

      In-Store Dashboard to keep operations streamlined

      Unified Commerce

      In-Store and Online orders unified

      Store Locator

      Drive foot-traffic to your stores

  • Integrations
  • Customers
    • Help Center

      Find the answer to all your questions

      WeSupply FAQ

      Explore the most comon questions about WeSupply

      Post Purchase ROI Calculator

      Calculate the ROI that WeSupply can bring you

      FREE Website Review

      Request a no strings attached review of your current shopping experience and missed conversion opportunities

      Blog & Guides

      Read actionable articles on how to optimize your post-purchase experience and decrease support tickets

      Case Studies

      Get inspired by stories of how our customers implemented an effortless post-purchase experience

      Behind The Brand

      A Deep Dive into Top Companies' Order Tracking & Returns Strategy

      Pre-built Return Policies

      Wondering if WeSupply is a good fit for you? Read through our use cases to see how we can help you increase conversion & improve CX!

  • Pricing

Sign in

Essential Return Metrics for Shopify Merchants to Master in 2024

WeSupply return analytics dashboard

Are you a Shopify merchant looking to optimize your return process and drive business growth? Essential return metrics for Shopify merchants are the key to understanding customer behaviors, managing costs, and boosting profitability. This article digs into the crucial data points like return rate, average return value, and customer refund patterns that will directly inform your strategy and operations. Explore how mastering these metrics can shape a customer-centric approach and enhance your bottom line.

Key Takeaways

  • Understanding and monitoring key return metrics such as the total sales, return rate, and average return value is essential for Shopify merchants to refine business strategies, improve online store conversions, and increase profitability.


  • Effective management of return, refund, and exchange rates is crucial for eCommerce business success; with detailed product descriptions and visuals playing a vital role in reducing returns and enhancing customer satisfaction.


  • Leveraging analytics tools beyond Shopify’s dashboard, embracing automation, and staying informed about emerging eCommerce trends like AI and sustainability in returns management can significantly optimize operations and create a customer-centric returns experience.


  • WeSupply is a powerful tool for Shopify merchants focused on mastering return metrics in 2024. It streamlines returns with robust analytics to reduce rates and enhance customer satisfaction. The platform automates processes, minimizes fraud, and encourages exchanges over refunds with flexible refund options and effective communication. WeSupply also helps optimize product quality and manage inventory efficiently, boosting customer loyalty and lifetime value. Ready to transform your returns process? Download the Official WeSupply Shopify App today!

Introduction to Return Metrics in eCommerce

Return metrics are the unsung heroes of the Shopify analytics dashboard. They are the behind-the-scenes numbers that provide a snapshot of your online store’s performance in the eCommerce industry. These metrics track the pulse of your customer returns, acting as a mirror reflecting your eCommerce store performance.

Return metrics offer a comprehensive understanding of your business’s health. They provide a treasure trove of insights that can help fine-tune your strategies, improve your online store conversion rate, and bolster your bottom line. Some key return metrics to track include:

  • Total sales

  • eCommerce returns

  • Return rate

  • Average return value

  • Return reasons

By analyzing these metrics, you can identify patterns and trends, make data-driven decisions, and optimize your business operations.

Understanding Shopify Return Metrics

Shopify return metrics are your guide to a better understanding of your customer returns. As a Shopify store owner, when you know your numbers, you can make more informed decisions, ultimately improving your eCommerce store performance. These metrics are like a compass, pointing you towards areas of improvement and showing you where you’re excelling.

From the return rate to the refund rate, these metrics to track provide a complete picture of your eCommerce site’s health. Understanding these Shopify analytics is the first step on your journey to a more profitable and customer-focused business.

Mastering the Return Rate

Return rates are a crucial pulse point for any eCommerce business. They reflect the percentage of sold items that customers send back, impacting revenue and operational costs. Keeping a close eye on these numbers and knowing how to interpret them can provide a competitive advantage.

But how do you calculate these rates accurately? And what is the industry norm? Let’s explore these questions in the following sections.

Calculating Your Store's Return Rate: Detailed method for accurately determining return rates

Calculating your store’s return rate is a precise process. It involves dividing the number of returned items by the total number of items sold within a specific timeframe, then multiplying the result by 100 to get a percentage.

This simple yet effective formula provides a clear picture of your net sales returns, helping you gauge your eCommerce store’s performance.

Benchmarking Against Industry Standards: How to compare your return rates with industry norms to gauge performance

Now that you have your return rate, it’s time to see how you stack up against the industry standards. With the average eCommerce return rate hovering around 30%, you can use this benchmark to gauge your store’s performance. Still, keep in mind that this rate can vary based on different factors like product category and seasonality.

For instance, clothing retailers often see higher return rates, and the holiday season typically sees an uptick in returns.

Mastering Return Rates with WeSupply's Analytics

WeSupply offers a robust Returns Analytics tool that enables businesses to master their return rates effectively. By identifying products that are most frequently returned and understanding the reasons behind these returns, WeSupply provides actionable insights. These insights empower businesses to make informed decisions that can significantly reduce their return rates, improving both customer satisfaction and profitability.

Optimizing Product Quality to Reduce Returns

Returns can be a headache, but they also offer valuable insights. They can be an indicator of product quality and how well your product descriptions match the actual items. By enhancing your product descriptions and visuals, you can minimize return rates and improve customer satisfaction.

Consider this: a well-crafted product description and clear, high-quality visuals can reduce the ‘guesswork’ for customers, helping them make more informed buying decisions. They can understand exactly what they are purchasing, reducing the likelihood of a mismatch between customer expectations and the actual product.

WeSupply helps optimize product quality by leveraging SKU-level returns analytics. This detailed analysis allows businesses to identify specific return reasons for products and variants, such as issues with color, quality, or size. By adjusting sizing charts, reviewing product images, encouraging more product reviews, and gathering customer feedback on fit, WeSupply enables companies to enhance their product offerings and reduce return rates effectively.

Refund Rate Revelations

Refunds are another crucial metric that can significantly impact your bottom line. Understanding your refund rate, how to calculate it, and how to minimize it is key to building a profitable business. But how exactly do we calculate the refund rate, and what can we do to keep it as low as possible?

Let’s delve deeper into these areas.

The Formula for Refund Rate Calculation:

Calculating the refund rate is similar to determining the return rate. You divide the number of refunded items by the total number of items sold and multiply the result by 100 to express it as a percentage. However, the implications of a high refund rate are far-reaching.

It can signal customer dissatisfaction and hint at potential issues with your products or services.

Minimizing Refunds Through Customer Engagement:

Engaging your customers effectively can be your secret weapon in minimizing refunds. Strategies can include:

  • Providing detailed product descriptions

  • Clear product imagery

  • Promoting exchanges

  • Educating customers post-purchase

Reviews are a particularly effective tool. Studies show that the majority of shoppers rely on reviews to make purchasing decisions, which can reduce returns. Speeding up the return process and clearly defining the returns timeline can also help recover more revenue by increasing the likelihood of reselling the products at full price.

WeSupply helps minimize refunds and enhances customer engagement through strategic incentives and communication. By converting returns into exchanges and incentivizing this process, WeSupply not only saves sales but also boosts the average order value. Key features include:

  • Flexible Exchange Options: Exchange return items for any product, the same item, an item of the same value, or a higher valued item.

  • Engaging Communications: Utilize post-purchase email and SMS notifications, which have a high open rate, to send return shipping notifications and personalized deals, keeping customers engaged and likely to return.

Discover the full potential of your returns process—book a WeSupply demo today!

Combat inconvenience with proactivity & self service

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply can help you make returns easy for your customers with a beautiful, self-service solution that makes their experience easier while also providing new ways to lower costs and earn back revenue.

Exchange Rate Efficiency

Exchanges are a win-win for businesses and customers alike. They help preserve revenue and enhance the customer experience. But how do you calculate the exchange rate, and how can you steer customers towards exchanges rather than refunds?

Let’s explore these questions further.

Exchange Rate Calculation Explained:

The exchange rate is determined by dividing the number of exchanges by the total number of returned orders and multiplying by 100 to get a percentage. Even though it sounds similar to the return and refund rates, the exchange rate has its unique implications.

A higher exchange rate than the refund rate is ideal, as it preserves your revenue and adds significant value to the customer experience.

Encouraging Exchanges Over Refunds:

Encouraging exchanges over refunds can be a game-changer for your business. It not only helps retain revenue but also enhances customer satisfaction. Employing effective post purchase communication, such as customer education through post-purchase emails about product use, can lead to fewer returns.

Offering quality tiles to communicate product value and implementing a fair yet liberal return policy can foster customer trust, further reducing the frequency of returns.

WeSupply effectively encourages exchanges over refunds by providing seamless and enticing options to customers, ensuring a boost in both customer retention and average order value. Key features include:

  • Incentives for Exchanges: Offer instant store credit to save sales and encourage customers to opt for exchanges instead of refunds, increasing the average order value.
  • Flexible Refund Options: Convert refunds into store credits, gift cards, or coupon codes to motivate customers to continue shopping, fostering loyalty and repeated business.

  • Easy Exchange Process: Make the exchange process straightforward by directing customers back to the website where they can choose from any product, using store credits or gift cards as partial payments to enhance the shopping experience and potentially increase the order value.

  • Enhance Customer Lifetime Value: By making exchanges appealing and easy, WeSupply helps businesses increase customer lifetime value through repeated engagements and satisfaction.

Leveraging Shopify Analytics Dashboard

The Shopify analytics dashboard is a powerful tool that can provide you with detailed analytics on returns. From understanding your return metrics to tracking trends over time, the dashboard equips you with the information you need to make informed business decisions.

With the right data at your fingertips, you can optimize your return process and create a more profitable and customer-centric business.

Leveraging Shopify Analytics Dashboard

Customer returns can provide a wealth of information about your business. By identifying patterns and triggers in return metrics, you can anticipate customer behavior and fine-tune your return management strategies. These key indicators can help you recognize potential issues before they escalate, enabling you to take corrective action promptly.

For instance, a sudden spike in returns could indicate a problem with a particular product or a change in customer behavior. Similarly, a decline in returns could signal an improvement in product quality or effectiveness of your return policies. By keeping an eye on these key performance indicators, you can stay ahead of the curve and continuously improve your business.

WeSupply provides essential insights into customer returns through its comprehensive Returns Analytics feature. This tool helps businesses understand key patterns and reasons behind product returns, enabling them to address customer dissatisfaction effectively. Key indicators include:

  • Returns by Region: Analyze geographical trends to identify specific areas with higher return rates.
  • Return Reasons: Gain a clear understanding of why customers return items, whether due to quality, size, or other factors.

  • Serial Returners: Recognize patterns in customer behavior by identifying individuals who frequently return items, allowing for targeted strategies to reduce such activities.

By leveraging these insights, companies can make informed decisions to improve product offerings and enhance customer satisfaction.

Streamlining Reverse Logistics

Effective reverse logistics can enhance efficiency in handling returns and reduce costs. It’s all about getting returned products back into your inventory as quickly and efficiently as possible. This process involves many moving parts, from receiving and inspecting returned items to restocking them and updating your inventory records.

WeSupply significantly enhances the efficiency of reverse logistics, making returns management seamless and less time-consuming for your team. By automating and streamlining the entire return process, WeSupply helps save up to 80% of the time typically spent on manual returns. Key features include:

  • Automated Returns: Automatically calculate product-specific restocking fees, apply vendor-specific return policies, and prevent return fraud by promptly identifying and stopping abusers.
  • Efficient Communication: Eliminate the need for continuous back-and-forth emails with customers, reducing the clicks needed to manage a return from request to refund.

  • Quality Control and Inventory Management: Inspect returns meticulously and manage inventory more effectively. Define quality check criteria, collect product images and feedback from customers, and allow warehouse staff to leave detailed notes on each return’s quality inspection.

These strategies not only simplify the returns process but also ensure that products are handled appropriately, maintaining quality and customer satisfaction.

Elevating Customer Lifetime Value Through Returns Analysis

Analyzing returns can provide insights that can significantly impact your business’s profitability. By managing returns effectively and crafting return policies that foster customer trust, you can boost your customer lifetime value. But how exactly do returns influence customer lifetime value, and how can a well-crafted return policy enhance loyalty?

WeSupply helps maximize ROI by elevating Customer Lifetime Value through insightful returns analysis. By understanding return patterns and customer behavior, businesses can improve product quality and customer satisfaction, leading to increased repeat purchases and loyalty. Try our ROI Calculator today to see the impact on your business!

Relationship Between Returns and Customer Lifetime:

Returns management goes beyond just handling returned items. It can play a crucial role in increasing customer lifetime value by providing more accurate projections of future customer spending and balancing acquisition and customer retention efforts. An effortless return process can indicate a brand’s commitment to customer satisfaction, potentially leading to increased loyalty and repeat purchases.

Research shows that 92% of customers are more inclined to make repeat purchases from a retailer if they find the return process easy. Therefore, by effectively managing returns, you can increase customer loyalty, resulting in higher profits for your business.

WeSupply helps businesses understand the crucial relationship between returns and customer lifetime value by providing detailed insights into the reasons and patterns of returns. By analyzing data such as returns by region and specific reasons for returns, businesses can uncover what drives customer dissatisfaction. This understanding allows companies to make strategic improvements in product quality and service, ultimately increasing customer lifetime value. WeSupply’s tools enable businesses to see how returns impact customer loyalty and retention, empowering them to enhance their offerings and strengthen their customer relationships.

Returns Analytics for eCommerce Business

Understand why your customers are returning: Identify the most returned products, Understand why those products are returned, Identify which customers are serial returners, Reduce Return Rate with Actionable Insights. Returns data available in BigQuery

Crafting a Return Policy That Enhances Loyalty:

A well-crafted return policy can significantly enhance customer loyalty. A clear and comprehensive policy builds consumer trust and can encourage more purchases. In fact, studies show that 61% of consumers review a store’s return policy before making a purchase decision.

Companies that offer hassle-free return processes, such as Amazon, Zappos, and Lululemon, achieve high levels of customer satisfaction and loyalty. By crafting a return policy that is easy to understand and customer-friendly, you can foster loyalty and create a competitive advantage for your business.

WeSupply’s pre-built return policies help businesses craft return policies that not only save time and money but also enhance customer loyalty. By automating return policies, companies can streamline the returns process, retaining more revenue and reducing operational costs. This automation ensures a consistent, fair, and transparent return experience for customers, which builds trust and encourages repeat business. Ultimately, WeSupply’s solutions foster a positive return experience that contributes to sustained customer loyalty and satisfaction.

Tools for Tracking and Improving Return Metrics

With the right tools at your disposal, tracking and improving return metrics can be a breeze. There are several sophisticated tools available that can automate returns management and provide analytics beyond Shopify’s dashboard.

Let’s explore some of these tools.

Automated Returns Management Systems:

Automated returns management systems can significantly streamline the returns process for you. Some tools that offer a range of capabilities include:

Optimizing Return Metrics with WeSupply's Automated System

WeSupply revolutionizes returns management with its automated system, making the process faster, more efficient, and customer-friendly. By integrating several key features, WeSupply reduces manual errors, fraud, and operational inefficiencies:

  • Self-Service Returns: Customers can easily initiate returns at any time without the need for support tickets or phone calls, enhancing user convenience.
  • Automated Restocking Fees: Automatically calculate product-specific restocking fees and apply vendor-specific return policies.

  • Fraud Prevention: Identify and stop return fraud effectively, protecting your business and maintaining trust.

  • Reduced Manual Intervention: Significantly cut down on the need for manual calculations and communications, reducing human errors and streamlining operations.

These features collectively improve the returns experience for both customers and retailers, fostering trust and efficiency in the return process. Streamline your returns today—download the Official WeSupply Shopify App!

Case Study about an Effective Returns Management System

Evereve faced significant challenges in managing fashion industry orders and returns, leading to a manual, time-consuming process with limited visibility and accountability. The lack of an efficient returns process caused data limitations, markdowns, and overwhelmed customer service teams. To address these issues, Evereve implemented WeSupply’s Magento & Custom API integrations, automating returns and centralizing management. This new approach, focused on proactivity, self-service, and flexibility, led to cost savings, faster and more accurate returns, and an improved customer experience. Evereve’s self-service returns have increased customer satisfaction and loyalty by empowering clients to manage their returns independently.

Read the full case study to discover how Evereve transformed their returns process and enhanced customer loyalty.

Future Trends in eCommerce Returns Management

As we look towards the future, innovative practices and emerging trends are shaping the landscape of returns in the eCommerce sector. Some of the key trends and practices that will shape the future of eCommerce returns management include:

  • The rise of AI and machine learning

  • Increasing focus on sustainability

  • Improved customer experience through streamlined returns processes

  • Enhanced data analytics for better insights and decision-making

  • Integration of technology to automate and optimize returns processes

The future of ecommerce businesses’ returns management is set to be exciting and transformative.

Staying abreast of these trends can help you stay competitive and create a profitable and customer-centric returns experience.

Conclusion: Building a Profitable and Customer-Focused Returns Experience

Mastering return metrics is critical for creating a profitable and customer-focused returns experience. From understanding key metrics to leveraging advanced tools, Shopify merchants have a wealth of resources at their disposal.

As we step into 2024, focusing on effective returns management can help you enhance customer satisfaction, reduce costs, and drive your business’s growth.


In conclusion, effective returns management is a cornerstone of a profitable and customer-centric eCommerce business. By understanding and tracking key return metrics, optimizing product quality, and leveraging advanced tools, Shopify merchants can enhance customer satisfaction and loyalty. As we look towards the future, staying abreast of emerging trends and innovative practices can help businesses stay competitive and create a winning returns experience.

WeSupply is a comprehensive solution for Shopify merchants aiming to master essential return metrics in 2024. Through its robust Returns Analytics, WeSupply empowers businesses to identify frequently returned products, understand return reasons, and tailor strategies to reduce return rates, thus enhancing customer satisfaction and profitability. The platform streamlines reverse logistics by automating the return process, calculating restocking fees, and implementing vendor-specific return policies, all while minimizing return fraud and human errors. Additionally, WeSupply promotes customer retention by encouraging exchanges over refunds, offering flexible refund options like store credits and gift cards, and maintaining effective communication through high-engagement tools like email and SMS notifications. By leveraging WeSupply, businesses can optimize product quality, effectively manage inventory, and craft return policies that boost customer loyalty and lifetime value. The integration of these features ensures a seamless, efficient, and customer-friendly returns management system.

Ready to optimize your returns process and enhance customer loyalty? Get started with WeSupply today!

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you calculate the return rate for a Shopify store?

To calculate the return rate for your Shopify store, divide the number of returned items by the total number of items sold within a specific timeframe, then multiply the result by 100 to get a percentage. This will help you evaluate and improve your store’s performance.

What is the average eCommerce return rate?

The average eCommerce return rate is approximately 30%, but it can vary depending on factors such as product category and seasonality.

How can I reduce the refund rate for my Shopify store?

To reduce the refund rate for your Shopify store, engage with customers effectively by providing detailed product descriptions, clear imagery, promoting exchanges, and educating customers post-purchase. These actions can help to lower your refund rate significantly.

How can WeSupply help reduce return rates?

WeSupply offers Returns Analytics that identifies frequently returned products and the reasons behind these returns. This insight allows merchants to make informed decisions to improve product offerings and customer satisfaction, effectively reducing return rates.

How does WeSupply encourage exchanges over refunds?

WeSupply facilitates exchanges by offering instant store credit and making the exchange process easy and appealing. Customers can exchange an item for any other product, use store credits or gift cards as partial payment, and even opt for higher valued items, enhancing customer retention and increasing order values.

Can WeSupply improve customer loyalty and lifetime value?

Yes, by understanding the relationship between returns and customer behavior, WeSupply helps businesses craft strategies to enhance customer loyalty. Analyzing returns by region and reasons, along with tracking customer return patterns, allows merchants to address dissatisfaction proactively, increasing customer lifetime value.

Does WeSupply have an Official Shopify App?

Yes. WeSupply has an Official Shopify App. You can download it and start integrating with your Shopify Store.

Does WeSupply have an official Magento extension?

Yes, WeSupply has an official extension for Magento. The WeSupply x Magento integration allows for automating order tracking experiences, reducing customer inquiries, automating shipping email and SMS notifications, and providing a fully branded order tracking experience

Does WeSupply have an official BigCommerce App?

Yes, WeSupply has an official BigCommerce App. You can integrate WeSupply with your BigCommerce store to improve your post-purchase customer experience.

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

WeSupply Post Purchase Emails
WeSupply Post Purchase Emails

Keep your customers engaged during the delivery experience

Jump Ahead!

In this article you'll learn:

Learn How To Create Successful Post Purchase Email Campaigns

Build an effective post-purchase email flow that helps you increase customer satisfaction and drive revenue growth!

Related articles